GREEN BAY, Wis. – In a game that left the NFL world buzzing, the Green Bay Packers and Dallas Cowboys delivered a record-setting spectacle, battling to a 40-40 tie on Sunday at AT&T Stadium. The contest, which lasted a grueling 3 hours and 47 minutes, marked the highest-scoring overtime tie in NFL history, surpassing the previous record of 74 points set by the 2014 Bengals-Panthers 37-37 draw. Described as “sweet but deadly” by fans and analysts alike, this game was a rollercoaster of momentum swings, costly mistakes, and relentless offensive firepower that left both teams exhausted and neither fully satisfied.
A Historic Night of “Weird”
The word of the night was “weird,” as players from both sides struggled to process the rare outcome. For Packers quarterback Jordan Love, it was his first career tie, a feeling he described as unsettling: “It sucks. It doesn’t feel good. It feels kind of weird. It’s my first time going through a tie.” Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott echoed the sentiment, noting, “In 10 years, it’s the first tie I’ve been a part of. It’s hard to wrap my head around it because I know I’d feel a lot worse if it was a loss.”
The tie was the 30th in NFL history since overtime was introduced in 1974 and the seventh for the Packers, their last coming in 2018 against the Minnesota Vikings. For Green Bay, the result preserved their undefeated streak at AT&T Stadium (5-0-1 against the Cowboys, 6-0-1 overall), but at 2-1-1, they remain behind the first-place Detroit Lions in the NFC North. The Cowboys, now 1-0-1 at home and 0-2 on the road, also left the game with mixed emotions.
A Game of Momentum and Mistakes
The game was a tale of two halves, with the first half defined by critical errors and the second by an offensive explosion. The turning point came at the end of the first half when the Packers, leading 13-9, squandered an opportunity to extend their advantage. Starting at their own 20-yard line with 41 seconds left and one timeout, Green Bay picked up a first down on a third-and-10 screen to tight end Tucker Kraft. However, a false start by Darian Kinnard pushed them back, and a sack/strip on the next play handed Dallas a golden opportunity. The Cowboys capitalized immediately, scoring to turn a potential 14-0 deficit into a 16-13 lead at halftime.
“Obviously, the end-of-half situation, turning the ball over and putting them in a scoring position was a turning point,” Love said. “I still think there’s so much more out there that we’ve just got to keep executing.”
A Wild West Shootout in the Second Half
The second half was nothing short of a Wild West shootout, with both teams trading blows in a relentless display of offensive prowess. After a Dallas punt to open the half, the teams combined for six consecutive touchdown drives:
-
Green Bay drove 76 yards for a touchdown to lead 20-16.
-
Dallas answered with an 80-yard touchdown drive to take a 23-20 lead.
-
Green Bay responded with a 70-yard touchdown drive to regain the lead, 27-23.
-
Dallas countered with a 77-yard touchdown drive to go up 30-27.
-
Green Bay marched 89 yards for a touchdown to lead 34-30.
-
Dallas drove 54 yards for a touchdown to take a 37-34 lead.
With time running out in regulation, the Packers managed a 39-yard field goal drive to force overtime. In the extra period, Dallas struck first with a 76-yard field goal drive to lead 40-37. Green Bay, undeterred, answered with a 64-yard drive of their own, culminating in a field goal to secure the 40-40 tie.
“It’s like right in the middle,” safety Xavier McKinney said. “It don’t feel like a win. It don’t feel like a loss. You’re just right in the middle.”
Standout Performances Amid the Chaos
Despite the tie, individual brilliance shone through. Packers running back Josh Jacobs, who had struggled to find running room in the first three games, erupted for 86 rushing yards and 71 receiving yards. “Weird. Honestly, that’s the only way I can really explain it,” Jacobs said, reflecting on the game’s outcome. “We kind of shot ourselves in the foot a little bit. Came out and tried to battle, had a chance to still win it at the end of the game.”
Jordan Love also delivered a strong performance, though he lamented missed opportunities: “Offensively, we did some good things. I still think we left a lot out there.” On the defensive side, the Packers struggled, surrendering 40 points after allowing just 44 points combined in their first three games. Defensive end Rashan Gary, who entered the game with a league-high 4.5 sacks, was held in check and expressed frustration: “It’s not up to our standard. All three phases of the ball, we got to be better, talking about myself included.”
For Dallas, their final seven possessions resulted in five touchdowns and one field goal, showcasing their offensive firepower but also highlighting defensive lapses that allowed Green Bay to stay in the game.
A Tie That Stings
The tie left both teams grappling with a sense of unfulfillment. For the Packers, it was a missed opportunity to assert themselves in the NFC North race. For the Cowboys, it was another overtime game at home that failed to yield a victory. Coach Matt LaFleur summed it up succinctly: “We didn’t come down here to tie a football game, but that’s what happened.”
As the NFL world reels from this “sweet but deadly” masterpiece, both teams will look to correct their mistakes and find ways to turn close calls into wins. For now, the Packers and Cowboys share a piece of history in a game that was as thrilling as it was frustrating, a high-scoring tie that will be remembered for years to come.