The Boston Red Sox and Seattle Mariners share more than just their recent exits from the American League playoffs in heartbreaking fashion. Both franchises are trending upward, boasting rosters brimming with young, controllable talent. Yet, as they head into the offseason, both face critical decisions in free agency to propel them toward a World Series. One decision for the Red Sox could be a game-changer: pursuing Seattle’s All-Star third baseman Eugenio Suárez, whose power-hitting prowess in the ALCS sent a loud message to Boston’s front office.
The Red Sox’s lineup has been missing a true home run threat. In 2025, Boston failed to produce a single 30-homer player, a stark contrast to their 2018 World Series-winning team when J.D. Martinez smashed 43. Enter Eugenio Suárez, a veteran slugger who has averaged 32 home runs per 162 games over his career. His standout performance in the ALCS, where he showcased his ability to launch balls out of the park, serves as a reminder of what Boston desperately needs. Suárez’s 49 career home runs against left-handed pitching make him an ideal candidate to fill the Red Sox’s power void, particularly as a designated hitter or occasional first baseman against lefty starters.
Boston’s interest in Suárez isn’t new. At the trade deadline, the Red Sox explored acquiring him, signaling they see a fit for his bat in their lineup, even alongside their own All-Star third baseman, Alex Bregman, who is also hitting free agency. While Bregman’s leadership and elite defense make him a priority to re-sign as the everyday third baseman, Suárez’s offensive profile offers a complementary piece. His ability to consistently deliver 30-plus homers could transform Boston’s lineup, providing the middle-of-the-order thump they’ve lacked.
However, Suárez isn’t without risks. At 35 next season, his age raises concerns about a multi-year deal. His on-base percentage dipped below .300 in 2025, and his defense at third base is below average, making him better suited for a DH role. Despite these drawbacks, his power is undeniable, and the Red Sox’s need for a home run hitter outweighs the concerns. A shorter-term contract could mitigate the risk while maximizing his offensive impact.
Re-signing Bregman should remain Boston’s top priority. His steady glove and leadership are invaluable at third base. But pairing him with Suárez could elevate the Red Sox to contender status. A lineup featuring Bregman’s consistency and Suárez’s raw power would address multiple needs without breaking the bank on pricier free agents like Kyle Schwarber or Pete Alonso. Suárez’s projected contract is likely more affordable, making a Bregman-Suárez tandem financially feasible.
The Red Sox could deploy Suárez primarily as a DH, with occasional starts at first base against left-handed pitchers, while Bregman anchors third. This alignment maximizes Suárez’s strengths—his bat—while minimizing his defensive liabilities. Boston’s front office has a chance to get creative, blending Bregman’s all-around game with Suárez’s home run-hitting ability to build a more complete lineup.
Suárez’s ALCS performance wasn’t just a highlight reel; it was a direct message to the Red Sox front office. Boston needs power, and Suárez delivers it in spades. His track record, combined with the team’s prior interest, makes him a logical target. While questions about his age and defense linger, his ability to change games with one swing is exactly what Boston has been missing.
This offseason, the Red Sox have a chance to make a bold move. Re-signing Bregman and adding Suárez could be the formula to push Boston closer to a World Series. The Mariners’ All-Star has made his case—now it’s up to Boston to listen.