Hannah from Love Island USA drops a shocking truth: Is she really in love with Charlie or Pepe? “It depends on how they feel!”

Hannah Fields, the 23-year-old fan favorite from Love Island USA, has left the villa but not the drama. Dumped alongside Jeremiah Brown on the June 22 episode of the hit Peacock series, Hannah broke hearts when she parted ways with Pepe Garcia-Gonzalez, leaving behind one of the villa’s strongest couples. Her journey, which began with Brit heartthrob Charlie Georgio before his unexpected exit, has now taken a new turn as she opens up about her feelings for both men—and whether a love triangle is brewing outside the villa.

A Tale of Two Connections

Hannah’s time in the villa was a whirlwind of emotions, marked by two very different but equally captivating connections. First, there was Charlie, the Birmingham native who brought laughter and a “romantic best friend” vibe to her days. “Me and Charlie just had this super funny dynamic,” Hannah shares with a smile. “We were always cracking up, probably annoying everyone with how loud we were, sneaking snacks in the pantry. It was like being with my best friend.”

But when Charlie was shockingly dumped on June 15, Hannah’s heart took a hit. She admits to crying herself to sleep next to a photo booth picture of him, a bittersweet reminder of their playful bond. Yet, the very next day, bombshell Pepe Garcia-Gonzalez swept her off her feet during a beach date that sparked an instant connection.

“Pepe was different,” Hannah reveals. “Our connection was deeper, more mature, but also super silly at times. A lot of our sweeter moments weren’t even shown on camera—people in the villa were always snapping pictures of us, saying how cute we were together.” While her time with Charlie was lighthearted and fun, Pepe offered something more profound, leaving Hannah torn between two incredible men.

The Unseen Moments with Pepe

Hannah hints that the cameras didn’t capture the full depth of her bond with Pepe. “Our connection was so real, but it wasn’t really shown,” she says. “We had these amazing moments that just didn’t make it to the screen.” From stolen glances to silly inside jokes, their relationship was a mix of heartfelt conversations and playful chemistry that had everyone in the villa rooting for them.

“Pepe and I had a super mature connection,” she adds. “But we could also be ridiculous together, which made it so special.” While her time with Charlie was cut short before they could dive deeper, Pepe became a steady presence, someone she could see a future with—both in and out of the villa.

A Love Triangle in the Making?

Now that she’s out of the villa, Hannah is reflecting on what’s next—and whether her heart belongs to Charlie or Pepe. “Both of them are amazing men,” she says. “I wouldn’t change a single thing about either connection. They were both so different, but so incredible in their own ways.”

As Pepe continues his Love Island journey, Hannah is cheering him on, even if it means he might find someone new in Casa Amor. “If I were still in the villa, I’d be losing my mind watching him explore other connections,” she admits with a laugh. “But now that I’m out, it feels different. He deserves the world, and if he finds someone who makes him happy, I’ll be okay with that. He’s not the type to force anything.”

Still, she can’t help but hope Pepe leaves the villa single. “I’ve got my fingers crossed that he comes out and we can see where things go,” she confesses, a spark of hope in her voice.

What’s Next for Hannah?

When it comes to the real world, Hannah is keeping her options open. “I’d definitely talk to both Charlie and Pepe,” she says. “The villa is such a unique environment—it’s intense, it’s fast, and it’s not real life. I want to see how our relationships could play out outside of that bubble.”

While she and Pepe had “a lot of chats” about a potential future together, her conversations with Charlie didn’t go as deep. Still, she’s not ruling anything out. “Only time will tell,” she says thoughtfully. “I’m not forcing anything. It really depends on how they both feel.”

A Journey of Heart and Hope

Hannah’s Love Island USA experience was a rollercoaster of laughter, tears, and unexpected connections. As she steps back into the real world, she’s carrying with her two unforgettable bonds—and a question that lingers: Will it be Charlie, the fun-loving best friend, or Pepe, the deep and soulful connection? For now, Hannah is letting fate decide, ready to embrace whatever comes next with an open heart.