The Boston Celtics’ playoff dreams were shattered when superstar forward Jayson Tatum suffered a devastating torn Achilles in Game 4 of the Eastern Conference Semifinals against the New York Knicks. Despite a valiant effort, the Celtics couldn’t overcome a 3-1 deficit without their best player, ultimately falling in six games. The loss was a bitter pill for Boston, but as the offseason begins, the focus shifts to recovery, rebuilding, and addressing the swirling debates surrounding Tatum’s superstar status.
Even with the Celtics out of the playoff picture, Tatum remains a lightning rod for discussion. FS1 analyst Colin Cowherd recently stirred the pot, comparing Tatum unfavorably to Oklahoma City Thunder star Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (SGA). Cowherd argued that SGA embodies the qualities often attributed to Tatum—but delivers them more consistently and assertively. “The many things I like about SGA is that he is delivering and fulfilling everything I’ve been told Jayson Tatum does,” Cowherd said. He pointed to last season’s Celtics championship run, where Jaylen Brown earned Eastern Conference Finals MVP and Finals MVP honors, often taking on the role of aggressor and initiator. In contrast, Cowherd sees SGA as the clear alpha on his team, surrounded by great players but always demanding the ball. “I’m holding Jayson Tatum to the standard you guys all lectured me on with years on LeBron [James],” Cowherd added, doubling down on his critique.
This isn’t the first time this season that Cowherd has targeted Tatum, and the criticism has only intensified the scrutiny on the 27-year-old star. Despite the backlash, Tatum’s talent is undeniable. Before his Achilles injury cut his postseason short, he was a force in the playoffs, averaging 28.1 points, 11.5 rebounds, 5.4 assists, and 2.1 steals per game over eight games, while shooting 42.3% from the field and 37.2% from three-point range in 40.3 minutes per game. These numbers highlight his versatility, clutch play, and ability to impact both ends of the court.
“He is delivering and fulfilling everything I’ve been told Jayson Tatum does.”@ColinCowherd discusses what sets SGA apart from other NBA star players. pic.twitter.com/FDi9FH08U8
— Herd w/Colin Cowherd (@TheHerd) May 29, 2025
However, doubters continue to question whether Tatum possesses the “alpha” mentality needed to lead a team to a championship as the undisputed top dog. Some argue his playoff performances, while impressive, lack the consistent dominance of players like LeBron James in his prime. Others point to teammate Jaylen Brown’s standout postseason as evidence that Tatum may not always be the primary catalyst for Boston’s success.
Still, there’s no denying Tatum’s importance to the Celtics. The former Duke standout has been a cornerstone of the franchise, and his recovery from the Achilles injury will be critical to Boston’s future. Achilles injuries are notoriously challenging, often requiring a lengthy rehabilitation process. For Tatum, the road ahead will test his resilience both physically and mentally as he faces ongoing debates about his place among the NBA’s elite.
As the Celtics regroup this offseason, they remain confident in their star. Tatum may not receive the universal respect some believe he deserves, but Boston is grateful to have him leading the charge. With his talent, work ethic, and proven clutch ability, Tatum is poised to silence his critics—assuming he can return to form after this devastating injury.