As the 2025 NFL season approaches, the Philadelphia Eagles and Pittsburgh Steelers find themselves at a critical juncture, with both teams eyeing a pivotal free-agent signing that could shape their Super Bowl aspirations. The player in question is none other than four-time All-Pro safety Justin Simmons, a veteran defensive back who remains unsigned as training camps loom. With both franchises poised for playoff contention, the race to secure Simmons’ services could determine which team takes a decisive step toward a championship. But who will win this high-stakes battle, and how might Simmons impact their future?
The Case for the Eagles
The Philadelphia Eagles, fresh off their Super Bowl LIX victory, are in a prime position to repeat as champions. However, their secondary faces questions after trading star safety C.J. Gardner-Johnson to the Houston Texans, creating a gap in their defensive backfield. Simmons, who has expressed strong interest in joining Philadelphia, represents an ideal fit. His familiarity with defensive coordinator Vic Fangio, under whom he thrived during his tenure with the Denver Broncos from 2019 to 2021, makes him a seamless addition to the Eagles’ split-safety defense. Simmons’ ball-hawking ability—evidenced by his 32 career interceptions, including a league-leading six in 2022—would bolster a secondary that already features young talents like Reed Blankenship and second-round pick Andrew Mukuba.
Simmons’ potential contract, projected at around $6 million for a one-year deal, aligns with Philadelphia’s cap space of approximately $26 million. General Manager Howie Roseman’s strategic approach to free agency suggests the Eagles could wait until after the 2025 NFL Draft to sign Simmons, avoiding compensatory pick penalties. This move would not only address an immediate need but also provide veteran leadership to a youthful defense, potentially solidifying Philadelphia’s status as a Super Bowl favorite. Simmons himself has publicly prioritized the Eagles, citing the opportunity to reunite with Fangio and play for a contender. If the Eagles act, they could lock in a proven playmaker to maintain their defensive dominance.
The Case for the Steelers
The Pittsburgh Steelers, perennial playoff contenders, are also in the market for a safety to elevate their secondary. With Aaron Rodgers now at the helm as their quarterback, the Steelers are doubling down on their championship ambitions for 2025. Simmons would add a dynamic presence to a defense that already boasts stars like T.J. Watt and Minkah Fitzpatrick. While the Steelers have a solid safety in Fitzpatrick, adding Simmons could create one of the NFL’s most formidable defensive backfields, capable of shutting down high-powered passing attacks. His 62 tackles, seven pass deflections, and two interceptions in 2024 with the Atlanta Falcons demonstrate that, at 31, he remains a high-level contributor.
Pittsburgh’s interest in Simmons is less publicized than Philadelphia’s, but the team’s need for depth and playmaking in the secondary makes him an attractive target. Head coach Mike Tomlin’s emphasis on mental and physical preparation for the 2025 season suggests the Steelers are looking for veterans who can elevate their roster. Simmons’ experience and discipline could complement Pittsburgh’s hard-nosed defensive identity, and his desire to finally reach the playoffs aligns with the Steelers’ consistent postseason appearances. However, the Steelers’ cap situation and their recent draft investment in Iowa running back Kaleb Johnson may limit their ability to pursue Simmons aggressively unless they prioritize him over other needs.
The Chiefs as a Dark Horse
While the Eagles and Steelers are the primary contenders, the Kansas City Chiefs cannot be overlooked. After losing to the Eagles in Super Bowl LIX, the Chiefs are eager to reclaim their throne. With Justin Reid’s departure to the New Orleans Saints, Kansas City has a vacancy at safety alongside Bryan Cook. Defensive coordinator Steve Spagnuolo’s creative schemes would likely maximize Simmons’ versatility, allowing him to roam as a free safety or contribute in coverage. However, Simmons’ comments about wanting to “beat” the Chiefs, stemming from his years of AFC West rivalry with them as a Bronco, suggest he may be less inclined to join Kansas City unless the offer is overwhelmingly compelling.
Who Will Win?
The battle for Justin Simmons comes down to fit, opportunity, and timing. The Eagles hold the edge due to Simmons’ vocal preference for Philadelphia and his history with Vic Fangio. The reigning champions have the cap space, schematic alignment, and immediate need to make this signing a reality. A one-year deal would allow Simmons to chase his first playoff appearance while mentoring younger players like Sydney Brown and Andrew Mukuba, potentially securing Philadelphia’s defense for another Super Bowl run.
The Steelers, while a strong contender, face stiffer competition within their roster and may prioritize other positions given their recent offensive additions. Pittsburgh’s chances hinge on Simmons valuing their consistent playoff pedigree and the opportunity to pair with Fitzpatrick. The Chiefs, though a viable option, seem less likely due to Simmons’ personal motivations and their already crowded defensive roster.
Ultimately, the Eagles are the frontrunners to land Simmons, likely after the 2025 NFL Draft to optimize their roster and cap strategy. His addition could solidify Philadelphia’s defense, giving them a critical edge in their quest to repeat as champions. The Steelers, while still in the race, may need to make a bolder financial or strategic move to outmaneuver Philadelphia. For now, the smart money is on Simmons donning the Kelly Green, potentially determining the Eagles’ future as they aim for back-to-back titles.