Casemiro will depart Old Trafford at the conclusion of the 2025/26 season—a move that has been virtually confirmed by club insiders. Emerging as the frontrunner to replace the Brazilian legend is Newcastle United’s Sandro Tonali.
According to sources close to both England and Italy (including Fabrizio Romano and The Athletic), Manchester United has placed Tonali at the top of their priority list for the Summer 2026 transfer window. The Red Devils are closely monitoring the Italian midfielder as he seriously considers his future, prioritizing consistent Champions League football.
Tonali – The “Perfect” Target for Michael Carrick’s Philosophy
Versatility: At 25, Tonali is a complete box-to-box midfielder: elite pressing, excellent ball recovery, precise passing, and a potent long-range shot.
Tactical Fit: He can excel as both a No. 6 (pivot) and a No. 8 (mezzala), aligning perfectly with the balance Carrick is building between defense and offensive support.
Experience: A Serie A winner with Milan and a veteran of top-flight European football, he is back to his peak form following his 2023 suspension.
Newcastle Will Not Let Him Go Cheaply Newcastle signed Tonali for £55m in 2023. Given his age and consistency, they are expected to demand at least £90–£100 million. With INEOS and Sir Jim Ratcliffe prepared to spend big (with a projected £200m summer budget), this figure is within reach—especially as Casemiro’s departure frees up nearly £20m in annual wages.
The Context for a Departure Newcastle currently sits 7th-8th in the Premier League, making Champions League qualification uncertain. Tonali wants the European stage to secure his spot in the Italian national team. Meanwhile, Man Utd under Carrick is playing attractive football and looks poised for a top-tier European return.
Conclusion Sandro Tonali is fast becoming the No. 1 target for United’s 2026 rebuild. If successful, a midfield trio of Mainoo – Ugarte – Tonali would be one of the most balanced and modern units in the world.
What do you think? Should MU spend £90-100m on Tonali, or look for a cheaper alternative like Zubimendi or Wharton? Let us know below!