Love Island All Stars is teetering on the brink after the latest bombshell twist sparked outright viewer revolt. Fans are calling for the entire series to be axed, branding the arrival of Lucinda Strafford and Curtis Pritchard as the final straw in a season that many now say has “lost all credibility”.
Curtis Pritchard and Lucinda Strafford arrived in the All Stars villa last night – but fans aren’t happyCredit: ITV
Curtis quickly made himself at homeCredit: ITV
A woman in a red halter dress on a white sofa with red cushions.
5Lucinda is a Love Island OG and even appeared on the Aussie version of the showCredit: ITV
©ITV
Last night’s episode was already explosive — islanders tore into each other during a brutal Never Have I Ever game — but the real chaos erupted when two familiar faces strolled into the villa garden: Curtis Pritchard, 29, and Lucinda Strafford, 26.
Both are now on their fourth Love Island appearance across various formats, and viewers at home were not here for the recycling.
Social media erupted within minutes:
“This is the best you can do? Just cancel All Stars after this season because you’re clearly struggling to get anyone good involved.”
“Not again!!! These two!”
“This IS why I can’t take All Stars seriously! It should be scrapped now.”
“Guys, you’re scraping the barrel at this point, come on!! Do better!”
The backlash is deafening. Many fans argue that repeatedly bringing back the same contestants has stripped the All Stars format of its magic, turning what was meant to be a celebration of the show’s greatest hits into a desperate grab for recognisable faces.
Curtis first entered the villa in 2019, famously coupling up with Maura Higgins after his heartbreaking split from Amy Hart. He returned for Love Island Games in 2023, then placed third in last year’s All Stars with Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu — a romance that fizzled just months later.
Lucinda’s journey is equally extensive: she appeared in series seven (2021), then headed to Love Island Australia season five, before winning the most recent series of Love Island Games.
Yet both insist they’re back for genuine reasons.
Lucinda explained: “I want to find real love, that would be amazing… I’ve been on a bit of a ‘Love Island’ journey over the past few years but I’ve not found the ultimate one. I’m single, so why would I say no? It’ll be a full circle moment.”
Curtis added: “Last series I left with Ekin-Su but that didn’t quite go to plan. I’m still getting older so hopefully I can find some love, or at least start another journey. I’ve never been a Bombshell before, so I’ll try and talk to everyone the first couple of days.”
He didn’t waste time, however, quickly pulling Millie Court for a private chat, while Lucinda was seen getting to know Jack Keating.
But for thousands of furious fans, the damage is already done. With calls for outright cancellation growing louder by the hour, producers now face an uncomfortable truth: recycle too many islanders, and viewers may walk away for good.
Is this the beginning of the end for Love Island All Stars? Watch this space.