The Real Housewives of New York City (RHONY) reboot has been stirring up drama both on and off the screen, and cast member Erin Lichy is spilling the tea on some jaw-dropping encounters with the franchise’s original stars. From Sonja Morgan’s baffling memory lapses to Ramona Singer’s brutal shade, Erin’s recent revelations on The Wellness Process podcast have fans buzzing about the divide between the old guard and the new.
Erin didn’t hold back when asked about her relationships with the OG cast members, sharing a particularly stinging anecdote about Sonja Morgan. “Sonja never remembers who I am,” Erin revealed with a mix of amusement and frustration. “I see her in the Hamptons, I’m like, ‘Hi,’ and she’s like, ‘Who are you?’” What makes this snub even more shocking? Erin and Sonja have hung out before. “We’ve, like, hung out, so she just doesn’t remember,” Erin added, hinting at Sonja’s perplexing forgetfulness. “I don’t know what happens. It’s really interesting.”
This isn’t just a casual oversight—it’s a bold dismissal that has left fans wondering if there’s more to Sonja’s behavior. Is it a deliberate slight, or is Sonja simply living in her own world? Either way, Erin’s story paints a picture of a frosty encounter that’s hard to forget.
If Sonja’s snub wasn’t enough, Erin shared an even wilder story about Ramona Singer that left her mother floored. Apparently, Ramona and Erin’s mom share the same building, and during a chance encounter, the conversation took a sharp turn. “My mom said something to her like, ‘Oh yeah, my daughter’s on the show now,’” Erin recounted. Ramona’s response? A blunt, “Oh, I don’t watch that. It’s doing terribly.” Talk about a mic-drop moment! Erin’s mom was left speechless, and fans can only imagine the awkward elevator ride that followed.
Ramona’s no-holds-barred comment reflects the ongoing tension between the RHONY reboot and its original cast. After 13 seasons, Bravo shook things up by replacing the veteran housewives with a younger, fresher lineup, a move that hasn’t sat well with some fans—or, apparently, Ramona. With ratings reportedly struggling, many viewers are clamoring for the return of the OGs, but Ramona’s shady remark suggests she’s more than happy to throw fuel on the fire.
Despite the chilly interactions with Sonja and Ramona, Erin had kinder words for other RHONY legends. “Luann is a blast. Dorinda is a blast,” she said, giving props to Luann de Lesseps and Dorinda Medley for their vibrant energy. She also revealed a surprising connection with Bethenny Frankel, noting, “Bethenny’s actually been very nice to me on DM.” These glimpses of camaraderie show that not all bridges between the old and new casts are burned—but the divide is still palpable.
Erin didn’t stop at spilling tea about her encounters. In a 2024 Access Hollywood interview, she took a subtle jab at the Real Housewives Ultimate Girls Trip featuring the original RHONY cast. “I watched a little bit. I thought it was cute,” she said with a laugh, her tone suggesting the Legacy season didn’t quite live up to the hype.
She also addressed swirling rumors about a potential mash-up between the reboot cast and the OGs. “I could tell you that [we’re] not joining forces with (RHONY) Legacy. It’s not happening,” Erin stated firmly. Her reasoning? Mixing the two groups would feel like “two separate groups almost battling each other.” It’s clear Erin sees the reboot as its own entity, and she’s not here for a forced reunion.
The drama doesn’t end with Erin’s revelations. Andy Cohen recently confirmed that the upcoming season of RHONY will introduce several new faces, shaking things up even further. Meanwhile, fan-favorite Brynn Whitfield announced her departure shortly after the last season, leaving viewers curious about the show’s direction. With tensions high and ratings under scrutiny, the reboot is at a crossroads—and Erin’s candid stories only add to the intrigue.